TEACHER DEVELOPMENT
Giving Feedback & Error Correction in the Classroom

Supporting Learners Through Effective Feedback

Feedback and error correction play a valuable role in the classroom. They influence how learners develop their English language skills, participate in classroom activities and build their confidence to communicate in English. 

Giving feedback is about more than identifying mistakes and providing the correct answers. Effective feedback on learners’ performance helps them to recognise what they are doing well, understand where they need to improve, and take an active role in identifying and addressing their own learning needs.

Based on practical teaching experience and classroom observations, this teacher development article explores how teachers can support language development by providing effective feedback and responding to learner errors. We include teacher development tasks to help you reflect on your current approach and experiment with different strategies in the classroom.

By the end of this article, you will be able to:

Task 1: Responding to Learners: When, How, What & Why?

Take a few minutes to reflect on your teaching practice in recent lessons and answer the following questions:

1. When / At what stages of the lesson did you provide feedback to students?

2. How did you provide feedback to the students?

3. What did you provide feedback on?

4. Why did you give feedback on those particular points?

» Pause & reflect (3-5 minutes)

The Role of Feedback and Error Correction in Language Learning

Feedback on learners’ performance is an important part of teaching and learning. Error correction is one key aspect of feedback in the language learning process. Feedback takes place in various formats at different stages of a lesson, and serves important purposes in the classroom, including:

1. Recognising achievements

Positive feedback helps learners understand what they are doing well and recognises the strengths in their language use and performance. Acknowledging progress and successes can make the learning experience more rewarding and give learners a sense of accomplishment.

2. Identifying areas for improvement

Constructive feedback highlights aspects of language use or task performance that learners should focus on and strengthen in future lessons or self-study.

3. Correcting errors

Error correction helps learners recognise mistakes in their spoken or written English, understand why something is incorrect and guides them to improve their language production.

4. Building confidence and motivation

Praise for successful work, together with regular feedback and error correction, can build learners’ confidence in their abilities, their progress, and motivate them to continue developing their language skills.

5. Guiding learner independence

Feedback gives learners an opportunity to reflect on their performance, recognise their strengths and identify areas they need to develop further. It can also guide learners towards becoming more independent in their language learning.

Task 2: What Role Does Feedback Play in Your Classroom?

Revisit your answers to Task 1, and consider whether your current approach addresses each of the five areas outlined above.

Note down specific examples of how you:

1. gave positive feedback to acknowledge learners’ achievements.

2. identified areas for improvement and helped learners address them.

3. responded to errors in spoken or written English.

4. used feedback to build confidence and motivate learners.

5. encouraged learners to reflect on their performance and take responsibility for their learning.

» Pause & reflect (5-8 minutes)

Teacher feedback

Giving Effective Feedback: What, When & How?

Giving effective feedback to learners depends on different factors. This includes the learning objectives, the type of activity and the individual needs of learners. Effective feedback requires teachers to consider:

What to give feedback on

Feedback commonly relates to whether learners have successfully achieved the objectives of the task and focuses on their accuracy or fluency in language production. It can include giving positive feedback, identifying areas for improvement, and error correction.

Accuracy

Accuracy refers to the correct use of language, including grammar, vocabulary and pronunciation. Based on the aims of the task, teachers can give feedback on accuracy when learners, for example:

Fluency

Fluency is the ability to express ideas smoothly and maintain communication. Teachers may give feedback on fluency when learners, for example:

Teacher tip
Think about what learners should be able to do by the end of a task, and whether it focuses on accuracy or fluency? Feedback that relates to these objectives helps learners recognise their achievements in relation to the lesson, and identify areas they could work on to develop their language skills.

Naturally, other aspects of learners’ language use may benefit from on-the-spot feedback about other points, but teachers should be careful not to let this distract from the main purpose of the task.

When to give feedback

Teachers should consider the purpose of an activity, the type of feedback required, and whether learners will benefit more from immediate or delayed feedback.

Making notes during activities is a useful way for teachers to keep track of learners’ language use and avoid relying solely on memory when giving feedback afterwards.

Immediate feedback

Immediate feedback from the teacher during a task is commonly used when:

Delayed feedback

On other occasions, it is more advantageous to provide delayed feedback, which occurs after an activity has finished. It can be used:

How to give feedback

Giving effective feedback also requires teachers to decide how it is communicated to learners to best support their language learning. Teachers should consider:

General vs Specific feedback

Giving general feedback can be encouraging for students. For example, teachers can recognise achievements by saying “good job” or “well done”.

On the other hand, giving specific feedback about a particular point with an example helps learners understand exactly what they have done well, where they need to improve and how they can make further progress. For example:

“You used the past simple well in most of your answers. Please take another look at today’s irregular verbs. We can practise them again tomorrow.”

Teacher tip
Teachers do not need to give detailed feedback about every aspect of language production. Even so, learners often rely on teacher feedback to measure their own progress. For that reason, specific feedback may be appreciated more than general feedback because it gives learners a clearer understanding of what they have done well and which areas they need to develop further. 

Whole class vs Individual feedback

Whole-class feedback enables teachers to address common areas of learners’ performance. All learners can benefit from shared feedback and it avoids singling out individual learners.

Individual feedback can be more personalised and focus on issues that are specific to a learner rather than the whole class. However, the timing and setting are important to ensure learners feel comfortable discussing their own performance.

Oral vs Written feedback

Oral feedback can be delivered in real time and allows teachers to use their tone of voice and body language to support their message. It also gives learners the opportunity to ask questions and seek clarification.

Written feedback can be provided after a task, and gives learners a record they can review after the lesson. It can be particularly useful for giving more detailed feedback.

Teacher vs Learner feedback

Teacher feedback can provide learners with clear guidance and suggestions for improvement. Learners may also have greater confidence in feedback from their teacher.

Learner feedback encourages learners to identify their own or each other’s strengths and areas for development, helping them become more independent in the learning process.

Task 3: Making Decisions About Feedback

Reflect on the approaches you use in the classroom, and consider whether there are opportunities to adapt your teaching practice:

1. Do you prioritise giving feedback that is related to the aims of the lesson or the task?

2. When and how do you typically provide immediate feedback?

3. When and how do you prefer to give delayed feedback?

4. Do you give learners clear examples of what they have done well and what they could improve?

5. Do you encourage learners to give feedback to one another? If so, how do you support them in doing this?

» Pause & reflect (5-8 minutes)

Learner error correction

Understanding Errors & Strategies for Correction

Error correction is an important part of the feedback process. To do this effectively, teachers need to recognise different types of errors, decide whether an error needs to be corrected, and choose suitable error correction strategies to help learners improve their language production.

Types of mistakes

All learners make mistakes as they develop their language skills, and learning from these errors is an important part of process. By recognising different types of errors, teachers can choose appropriate correction strategies to help learners improve further. Common types of mistakes include:

Slips

Slips occur when learners make ‘accidental’ mistakes. They would usually be able to recognise and self-correct when given the opportunity. Slips can happen when the learner is nervous, tired, or speaking quickly.

Example
“I go to the cinema yesterday.”
This would be a slip when the learner understands and normally uses the past simple correctly.

Errors

Errors occur when learners make mistakes because they do not yet know or fully understand a language point. As a result, they may be unable to recognise or correct these errors themselves.

Example:
“I made lots of photos on holiday.”
This would be an error when the learner has not yet learnt the correct collocation, “to take photos”.

Teacher tip
Errors can sometimes occur because of interference from the learner’s first language. For example, a German-speaking learner may say “I make photos” instead of “I take photos” because it is a direct translation of „Ich mache Fotos“.

Being aware of these differences can help teachers understand why certain errors occur and provide more targeted feedback. Of course, this can be more difficult in multilingual classes, where learners have different first-language backgrounds.

To Correct or Not to Correct?

Teachers should consider the type of mistake, and whether correction will support the learners’ progress. This decision making process can also be part of lesson planning, in which teachers predict potential mistakes that may occur in the lesson.

It is also worth noting that some learners expect regular error correction as part of their learning process. However, too much correction may have a negative impact on others. Therefore, teachers need to find a balance that takes into account the progress and preferences of their learners.

Reasons for correction

Some errors benefit more from correction than others, and teachers should consider:

Reasons to avoid correction

On the other hand, too much correction can also have disadvantages for learners, as it can:

Strategies for error correction

Once teachers have decided which errors to address, they can choose an appropriate correction strategy.

Some approaches involve teacher-led input, while others encourage learners to take a more active and independent role in identifying and correcting errors. This may include self-correction, where learners recognise and correct their own errors, or peer correction, where learners help one another to do so.

Common techniques include:

Explicit correction

Explicit correction is a direct correction technique given by the teacher. The teacher identifies the learner’s error and provides the correct form with an explanation. For example:

Learner: “I buyed some food at the supermarket.”
Teacher: “Good, but we should say, ‘I bought some food’ because ‘buy’ is an irregular verb.”

Reformulation (Recasting)

Reformulation (Recasting) is an indirect correction technique given by the teacher. The teacher repeats what the learner has said, but uses the correct language without explicitly highlighting the mistake. For example:

Learner: “I buyed some food at the supermarket.”
Teacher: “So, you bought some food at the supermarket. What did you buy?”

Elicitation

Elicitation is a learner-centred technique. The teacher uses a prompt to encourage learners to produce the correct language themselves. For example:

Learner: “I’m interested on music.”
Teacher: “Interested… in or on?”

Repetition

Repetition is another technique that encourages learners to correct their own mistakes. The teacher repeats what the learner has said up to the point where the error occurs, often with rising intonation to draw attention to the mistake.

Learner: “There is some great museums in London.”
Teacher: “There is?” (with rising question intonation).

Clarification requests

Clarification requests involve asking learners to reconsider their language use, giving them an opportunity to recognise and correct errors.

Learner: “I have been to London last year.”
Teacher: “Sorry, what did you do last year?”

Task 4: Giving feedback in future lessons

Think of one or two upcoming lessons and identify the lesson aims and key stages.

1. At which stages will you prioritise feedback on accuracy and fluency? Why? Give examples.

2. At which stages will you prioritise immediate and delayed feedback? Why? Give examples.

3. Try to predict potential errors that may occur during different tasks, and suggest effective feedback that will support the learners. Give examples.

4. Consider which error-correction strategies could support your learners for the different tasks. Give examples.

5. How will your feedback promote greater learner independence? Give examples.

» Pause & reflect (5-10 minutes)

Task 5: Reflect after teaching future classes

After teaching future lessons, reflect on your use of feedback and error correction for further development.

1. How and when did you give positive feedback to recognise learners’ achievements? Was it general or more specific? 

2. How did your feedback and error correction relate to the aims of the tasks in the lesson?

3. Which error-correction strategies did you use? Why?

4. Did you encourage learners to recognise and correct their own mistakes? How did learners respond and did they need further support?

5. What would you change or develop in your approach to feedback and error correction in the future?

» Pause & reflect (5-10 minutes)

Key Takeaways for Effective Feedback & Error Correction

Here are our key takeaways for giving feedback and error correction in the classroom.

Share with other teachers

You may also be interested in...